[Paul Fromm in Canada sent me this. Jan]
Read the CBC report below. It tells the story of Fort McMurray Ward 1 councillor Shafiq Dogar. At some point in the past he is alleged to have made comments critical of native people, during a February budget meeting, Critics said the comments were "hateful" or "hate speech". There were calls for him to resign. Recently, Council voted to censure him, restrict his powers and send him off to indoctrination school.
"The sanctions include removing Dogar from council committees and from representing council, including travelling on council business, until he has completed training on Indigenous awareness and respectful interactions at the municipality. Council also voted to issue Dogar a motion of censure and demand that he provide a public apology directed to the community and Indigenous communities."
Nowhere in the article will you learn what Dogar actually said. All too often the false news media leads the charge. It smears the victim with loaded words — "hate speech" — but denies readers specifics on which to form their own opinion.
Some research gets us a little closer to specifics. Fort McMurray Today (February 3, 2022), the local free handout, reported: "Mayor Sandy Bowman and Indigenous leaders in the Fort McMurray Wood Buffalo region are demanding Councillor Shafiq Dogar resign and are accusing him of saying Indigenous people come to Fort McMurray to get drunk, fight or cause legal problems."
Notice, Dogar’s critics do not say his remarks are false, just that he shouldn’t have said anything negative about a privileged minority. Locals will tell you that many Indians descend on Fort McMurray from reserves in the area and some, not all, get involved in heavy drinking or other legal problems.
In a functioning democracy, Ward 1 voters should decide Dogar’s fate. An elected official should be free to express his opinion to represent his constituents without fear of censure, reduced powers or a trip to indoctrination camp.
Canadian Association for Free Expression
Wood Buffalo councillor reprimanded for comments about Indigenous people
6 complaints were filed about Coun. Shafiq Dogar’s conduct and comments
Politicians, leaders and residents called for Coun. Shafiq Dogar’s resignation after comments he made about Indigenous people in the region. (VoteDogarShafiq.com)
A Fort McMurray councillor for the Regional Municipality of Wood Buffalo has been reprimanded for his conduct, including comments he made about Indigenous people at a February budget meeting.
Chief legislative officer Jade Brown detailed reports from the municipality’s integrity commissioner about Coun. Shafiq Dogar at a council meeting Tuesday.
Brown said formal complaints were made against Dogar for incidents in 2021 — in one instance about his interactions with a municipal employee and in another instance relating to Facebook posts he made.
Six other complaints were filed against Dogar about comments he made at a budget meeting in February of this year.
Wood Buffalo, Indigenous leaders call on councillor to resign
At the February budget meeting, Dogar made comments that Indigenous leaders and politicians said were hateful against Indigenous people.
The following day, the Athabasca Tribal Council called for Dogar to resign over his "hate speech." Wood Buffalo Mayor Sandy Bowman issued a statement calling Dogar’s comments "unacceptable, incorrect and difficult to comprehend."
Integrity commissioner Jim Peacock investigated the complaints against Dogar.
Peacock found that Dogar violated council’s code of conduct. Among other things, the code prohibits councillors from speaking in a discriminatory way, using abusive language or disclosing confidential information.
Council voted unanimously Tuesday to support a list of recommendations from Peacock. Dogar left the room for the vote.
The sanctions include removing Dogar from council committees and from representing council, including travelling on council business, until he has completed training on Indigenous awareness and respectful interactions at the municipality.
Council also voted to issue Dogar a motion of censure and demand that he provide a public apology directed to the community and Indigenous communities.
A governance expert will be enlisted to help in Dogar’s training. The expert will provide a report to council before the councillor is permitted resume his duties.
After the vote, Dogar was given an opportunity to speak. He started by defending himself against the first two complaints.
He then moved on to the incident in February. Dogar said other councillors and the mayor didn’t bat an eye when he made the comments, and that it was only afterward — when the Athabasca Tribal Council issued a news release — that they raised issue with his comments.
But he said he was ready to apologize during council.
Dogar then started talking about a meeting about extending the chief administrative officer’s contract. Coun. Keith McGrath called a point of order.
"Sir, let me speak today," Dogar said before his microphone was turned off.
The mayor upheld the point of order and Dogar was allowed to continue.
Councillor apologizes during meeting
Dogar said that over the past few months he has opted to take training as he realized his English "leads to some misunderstanding at times … I apologize to anyone whom I have neglected with my current speech."
He added: "We have a lot of good work to do in the community. Let’s do it. Let’s not waste time on unnecessary things."
McGrath said he felt the apology was sincere. He said Dogar should be commended for his apology.
Coun. Funky Banjoko said she applauded Dogar’s apology.
"And on behalf of the entire immigrants in the region, I also want to join him and apologize," Banjoko said.
But Coun. Kendrick Cardinal wanted more.
"I still think that you could do better. You didn’t specifically acknowledge the Indigenous people," said Cardinal. "I think you should."
Dogar then said he "always loved Indigenous people."
"We should acknowledge that this land we have to … we owe loyalties to the First Nation," he said.
Cardinal said Dogar’s additional words mean a lot to Indigenous communities and he acknowledged the apology. (CBC, May 25, 2022)